
Listening to your people can correct a marketing strategy, uncover a financial problem, expose an operational inefficiency, reveal raw customer feedback, or apprise the CEO of an employee relations issue that could lead to a costly lawsuit.
Sometimes, however, the consequences of not listening are almost unimaginable.
On January 28, 1986, Americans witnessed one of those moments when the space shuttle Challenger was lost just 73 seconds into its flight. Before I get to that catastrophic event, and the warnings that preceded it, I want to tell two very different business stories about the consequences of ignoring dissent, uncomfortable information, and the people willing to speak the truth.
When the Boss Denies the Truth
Patrick Lencioni, bestselling author and organizational expert, tells the story of a brilliant, famous, and intimidating CEO whose executives had learned not to disagree with him. His head of HR finally confronted the problem, warning him that because no one would challenge him, he was no longer benefiting from the judgment of the people around him. A 360-degree assessment was conducted, and the CEO received uncomfortable feedback about his leadership.
Everyone Knew the Truth but No One Wanted to Say It
When he gathered his executives around the table and went through several leadership criticisms one by one, something extraordinary happened. The people who had provided the feedback began backing away from it. They reassured him that he was doing fine.
Finally, Lencioni interrupted and pointed out the obvious: the people sitting in that room were the only ones who had completed the survey. One executive finally admitted that he had criticized the CEO and explained why. Instead of others joining him, another executive immediately distanced himself from the criticism, and the rest followed. The truth had finally entered the room, and almost no one was willing to stand beside it.
The Reassurance He Wanted Cost Him the Truth He Needed
The CEO got the reassurance he wanted, but according to Lencioni, he lost something far more valuable: credibility and trust. This once incredibly successful company eventually spun out of control and went out of business. Lencioni’s point was that its strategic and product problems were downstream symptoms of something deeper: there was no trust on the leadership team, beginning with a leader who could not make himself vulnerable enough to accept uncomfortable feedback. Bottom line, he would not accept the truth.
That is the lesson for every leader: getting people to tell you the truth is only the beginning. You must be willing to hear it, confront it and act on it. Great organizations do not become great because they have fewer problems. They become great because they deal with reality before reality deals with them.
“The truth will set you free, but first it will piss you off.”
— Joe Klaas, author of The Twelve Steps to Happiness
Power Has a Way of Silencing the Room
Ed Catmull, Pixar co-founder and author of Creativity, Inc., understood that telling the truth at work requires more than courage from employees. It requires humility from leaders. Catmull wrote, “Candor could not be more crucial to our creative process.” He believed in protecting candor so strongly that he persuaded Steve Jobs not to attend Pixar’s Braintrust meetings, concerned that Jobs’ powerful presence could influence the room and make people less willing to speak freely.
When Silence Becomes a Business Risk
A DecisionWise study of more than 100,000 U.S. employees found that 34% did not speak up because they feared retribution. A 2026 Radical Candor survey found that 61.3% of individual contributors often see people stay silent when they hold a different opinion, while 45.8% of executives said a lack of honest feedback was their primary concern. Silence should never be mistaken for agreement.
“Silence, not dissent, is the one answer that leaders should refuse to accept.”
— Warren Bennis, renowned leadership scholar and author
A 2024 review published in the European Journal of Training and Development examined 192 studies on workplace silence. Researchers found that leadership plays an important role in whether employees speak up or remain silent, and that silence can affect employee psychological health, performance, and broader organizational outcomes.
Bad News Is Business Intelligence
Bad news delivered early is not disloyalty. It is business intelligence. Discomfort does not make information less valuable. It may make it more valuable.
“The day soldiers stop bringing you their problems is the day you have stopped leading them.”
— General Colin Powell, former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
Seventy-Three Seconds
When the space shuttle Challenger lifted off that January morning, it carried seven crew members, including Christa McAuliffe, the teacher chosen for NASA’s Teacher in Space Project. Seventy-three seconds later, Challenger catastrophically exploded on live TV, and all seven crew members perished.
The Warnings Were There
For NASA leaders, the most disturbing part happened before liftoff. There had been warnings.
The presidential Rogers Commission found that contractor Morton Thiokol had initially recommended against launching over concerns about low temperatures and the rocket motors’ joints and seals. These joints used rubber O-rings as seals. For years, engineers raised serious concerns about the effectiveness of the O-rings, but management at both NASA and Morton Thiokol refused to respond adequately to those warnings.
The report specifically says that NASA “did not accept the judgment of its engineers that the design was unacceptable.” As the warnings increased from engineers, NASA minimized them in management briefings and reports. The leaders refused to come to grips with the truth. Those engineers might as well have not existed.
The Best Workplaces Make It Safe to Speak
Leadership must create an environment where it is psychologically safe to deliver bad news. When there are repercussions after raising your hand, it will create a chilling effect for team members to deliver bad news that could save a company.
Great Place To Work, Fortune’s partner on the 100 Best Companies to Work For list, reported that the 2026 list of companies had psychological and emotional health levels of 81%, compared with 56% at a typical U.S. workplace. Employees who feel psychologically safe are 44% more likely to feel confident in their leaders and more than twice as likely to stay.
“Followers who tell the truth, and leaders who listen to it, are an unbeatable combination.”
— Warren Bennis, renowned leadership scholar and author
The Truth May Save Your Organization
Great leaders make it safe to bring them bad news. They listen, ask questions, examine evidence and resist attacking the messenger. The employee delivering uncomfortable information may be giving the organization time to correct a mistake or prevent a crisis.
The next time someone walks into your office with something you do not want to hear, listen carefully. The truth may anger you or even prove you wrong, but it may also save your organization.

Sources
Patrick Lencioni, talk on CEO 360-degree feedback. YouTube.
Ed Catmull, Creativity, Inc. (Random House, 2014).
DecisionWise/TMA Performance, “34% of US Employees Don’t Speak Up for Fear of Retribution,” May 17, 2021. tmaperformance.com.
Radical Candor, “State of Workplace Feedback & Culture 2026.” radicalcandor.com.
“Organizational silence and employee silence: a systematic literature review,” European Journal of Training and Development. Emerald.
Report of the Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident (Rogers Commission), 1986.
Great Place To Work, “Announcing the 2026 Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For,” April 1, 2026. greatplacetowork.com.
___
Kevin Kennemer is a workplace strategist, writer, speaker, and founder of LifeatWork, with more than 30 years of experience helping organizations turn culture and leadership into measurable business performance. While he is an expert in compensation and benefits plan design and communication, his work connects a strong workplace culture directly to revenue growth, stronger customer loyalty, and increased market share, making culture a competitive advantage, not simply an employee initiative.
Discover more from LifeatWork
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
