From Worst to First

A dejected football coach walks off the field, hands in his pockets, as a stern executive points him toward the exit. Behind him, the scoreboard reads 63 to 0 and his players sit with heads bowed.

Your People May Not Be the Problem

I am fascinated by sports teams that are among the worst one season and the following season they are among the best. Finding the recipe to make these magnificent turnarounds is what every CEO should want to know.

The data says the difference between worst and first is not always better people. Sometimes it’s a better environment for the same people to succeed.

Every January, on the day after the NFL regular season ends, the losing teams start firing their coaches. Reporters call it Black Monday. Owners promise a fresh start, fans have new hope. The next season, many of those teams do get better.

Here’s what the owners won’t tell you: most of them would have gotten better anyway.

When researchers analyzed over 8,000 Belgian soccer games, they found that teams did improve within a few games of firing a coach. But the new coach was not the reason. Statisticians call it regression to the mean: when results hit an extreme low, part of the cause is usually bad luck, and luck evens out.

A golfer who averages 80 and shoots 95 will probably score closer to 80 next time, with or without new clubs. Studies of Dutch and Spanish soccer reached the same conclusion. Teams that kept their coaches bounced back just as often.

CEOs make the same bet. When results slide, they replace the leader(s), announce a restructuring and wait. About 70% of major transformations fail to meet their goals, according to McKinsey.

When McKinsey’s Scott Keller and Colin Price examined why, 39% of failures traced employee resistance and 33% to management behavior that didn’t support the change. Only 14% came down to a lack of resources.

Nearly three in four failed turnarounds break down over people, not plans.

So, here’s the truth behind worst-to-first stories: a new leader doesn’t turn an organization around. A new leader who changes the conditions people work in does.

“Businesses often forget about the culture, and ultimately, they suffer for it because you can’t deliver good service from unhappy employees.”

— Tony Hsieh, Former CEO of Zappos

In 1982, General Motors closed its Fremont, California, plant, one of its worst, where absenteeism often topped 20%. Two years later, GM and Toyota reopened it as New United Motor Manufacturing, Inc. (NUMMI), with a new production system and a much-improved relationship between managers and workers. About 85% of the workforce came from the old plant. Absenteeism fell to about 2%, and within a year, quality went from GM’s worst to GM’s best.

Same people. Different environments.

So, what do the leaders who climb out of last place actually do?

1. They make it safe to deliver bad news.

Ford lost $12.7 billion in 2006, the worst year in its 103-year history. New CEO Alan Mulally asked his executives to rate their projects green, yellow, or red every week. For weeks, every slide was green, even as the company bled money.

Then one executive finally had the guts to show red. He was essentially telling the CEO, “We have a problem. We suck here.” But instead of getting angry, Mulally applauded him because one of his executives had finally told the truth.

That moment changed the room.

“Productive change begins when you confront the brutal facts.”

— Jim Collins, Author of Good to Great

Once people realized they could admit what wasn’t working without getting punished for it, the real problems began surfacing. Problems that had been hidden could finally be confronted and solved. By 2009, Ford had returned to profitability, earning $2.7 billion without taking the government’s bailout funds that rescued its Detroit rivals.

2. They bring the front line into the turnaround.

In a McKinsey survey on transformations, only 3% of respondents reported success when their companies failed to engage line managers and frontline employees. When the leaders created an environment that encouraged engagement, success rates rose to 26% and 28%, roughly nine times better.

“The only variable are the conditions inside the organization. That’s where leadership matters, because it’s the leader who sets the tone.”

— Simon Sinek, Leadership Author and Speaker

Leaders may not control the forces around their organization, but they have tremendous influence over the environment their people work in every day.

People are far less likely to resist a change they help build.

3. If they have to cut, they cut smart, keep investing and stay patient.

Harvard researchers studied 4,700 companies through three recessions; only 9% came out stronger. The winners didn’t simply slash costs. They ran leaner while continuing to invest in growth.

Patience matters too. When Dan Campbell took over the Detroit Lions in 2021, the turnaround looked anything but promising. The Lions went 3-13-1 his first season, then started the next season 1-6. After 24 games, Campbell’s record was a miserable 4-19-1.

“No matter how great the talent or efforts, some things just take time.”

— Warren Buffett, Legendary Investor and Chairman Emeritus of Berkshire Hathaway

It would have been easy to decide the experiment had failed and start over again.

Detroit didn’t.

The Lions won eight of their final 10 games in 2022 and finished 9-8. A year later, they went 12-5, won their first division championship in 30 years and then won their first playoff game since 1991.

Sometimes a turnaround requires changing direction. Sometimes it requires having the patience to let the new direction work.

The Choice Every Leader Faces

Jim Collins studied over 1,400 companies for his book, Good to Great, and found only 11 that made a sustained leap to greatness. All of those 11 companies had a humble, determined leader during the transition, and 10 of the 11 came from inside the company. No celebrity savior required.

“Great vision without great people is irrelevant,” Collins wrote. NUMMI suggests the great people may already be on your payroll, waiting for an environment that lets them show it.

That’s the good news hiding in the research. You don’t need to wait for a new coach or a bigger budget to start climbing.

Before you fire anyone, ask a harder question: Have we created an environment where good people can win?

From Worst to First: the data. 01, the Black Monday myth: firing the coach gets the credit, luck does the work. When results hit an extreme low, part of the cause is usually bad luck, and luck evens out. Statisticians call it regression to the mean. What is regression to the mean? When results are unusually bad, part of the cause is usually bad luck that won't repeat, so the next stretch tends to drift back toward normal on its own. Example: a golfer who averages 80 and shoots a 95 will probably score close to 80 next time, with or without new clubs. A study of 8,392 Belgian soccer games found teams improved within four games of a new coach because of regression to the mean, and Dutch and Spanish teams that kept their coach bounced back just as often.
02, why turnarounds fail: about 70% of major transformations miss their goals; 39% of failures trace to employee resistance, 33% to unsupportive management, 14% to lack of resources and 14% other. 03, GM's worst plant became its best: GM and Toyota reopened the Fremont plant in 1984 as New United Motor Manufacturing, Inc. (NUMMI). After improved relationship between management and employees, about 85% of workers came from the old plant, absenteeism fell from over 20% to about 2%, and quality went from worst to best in GM within about a year.
04, make it safe to deliver bad news: when the truth came out, Ford turned around. Alan Mulally applauded the first executive brave enough to show a red slide. Ford lost $12.7 billion in 2006, its worst year in 103 years, and earned $2.7 billion in 2009 while Detroit rivals took rescue funds. 05, bring the front line into the turnaround: McKinsey found transformations succeed 3% of the time when neither line managers nor frontline employees are engaged, versus 26% and 28% when each is engaged.
06, the environment is the multiplier: Gallup found managers account for 70% of the variance in team engagement; the most-engaged business units see 23% higher profitability, 78% less absenteeism, 18% higher sales productivity and 14% higher productivity. 07, cut smart and keep investing: most companies stumble after a recession and only 9% come out stronger. Harvard researchers tracked 4,700 public companies through the recessions of 1980, 1990 and 2000: 17% didn't survive (went bankrupt, were bought or went private) and 9% came out stronger, growing sales and profits at least 10% faster than rivals. The 9% cut costs by running more efficiently, not just by slashing, and kept investing more than rivals in R&D, marketing and new equipment.
08, stay patient: the Detroit Lions under Dan Campbell went 3-13-1, started 1-6 the next year, then finished 9-8 and 12-5 with their first division title in 30 years. Other teams gave their coach time: Tom Landry's Cowboys had five losing seasons to start, then won Super Bowl VI; Bill Belichick's Patriots went 5-11 in 2000, then 11-5 and won Super Bowl XXXVI; Kyle Shanahan's 49ers went 6-10 and 4-12, then 13-3 and reached the Super Bowl in 2019. 09, no celebrity savior required: Jim Collins studied 1,435 companies; 11 became great and 10 of 11 leaders came from inside. Before you fire anyone, ask: Have we created an environment where good people can win?

___

Kevin Kennemer is a workplace strategist, writer, speaker, and founder of LifeatWork, with more than 30 years of experience helping organizations turn culture and leadership into measurable business performance. While he is an expert in compensation and benefits plan design and communication, his work connects a strong workplace culture directly to revenue growth, stronger customer loyalty, and increased market share, making culture a competitive advantage, not simply an employee initiative.

Published by Kevin Kennemer

Owner | Culture and Total Rewards Consultant | Writer Works with senior executives to build great places to work, best-in-class employee benefits, and communication strategies.

Leave a Reply